Questions, answered.
Welcome to The Gilt List FAQ. Whether you’re trying to find a romantasy book that actually delivers on its tropes, looking for free tools to plan your novel, or wondering whether your manuscript needs a developmental editor, you’re in the right place.
The Gilt List is home to honest book recommendations, reviews, publishing commentary, free writing tools, and editorial services. You’ll find answers about the site, our resources, and the help available for readers and writers below.
FOR WRITERSUse the free toolsBuild your world, shape your plot, or revise your opening.↗
EDITORIAL SUPPORTChoose your editFirst chapters, whole-manuscript critiques, and developmental editing.↗
A little about us
What The Gilt List covers, who is behind it, and why the reader comes first.
What is The Gilt List?
The Gilt List is an independent book platform for readers who want better recommendations and writers who want to create books people struggle to put down.
I cover popular fiction, review books from a reader’s perspective, look at publishing trends, and explore the craft behind stories that work. On the writing side, I offer free planning and revision tools alongside professional developmental editing services.
What genres does The Gilt List cover?
The Gilt List currently focuses on romantasy, fantasy romance, fantasy, paranormal romance, viral books, Kindle Unlimited discoveries, and darker, twistier fiction.
We’re also expanding into broader romance coverage, so expect more recommendations, reviews, and genre discussions beyond fantasy settings. Apparently, fictional relationships can be complicated without a magical blood oath involved. Who knew?
Who runs The Gilt List?
Hi, I’m Melissa Jay. I’m a writer, reader, and developmental editor with training and certification through the Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA).
I’ve worked on fantasy manuscripts, including a self-published book that went on to become an Amazon category bestseller. My background also includes digital marketing and SEO, which gives me an interest in how readers discover books, what makes them buy one, and what happens when the story doesn’t deliver what they expected.
Reviews & finding your next read
Find the right book without having to gamble on the blurb.
Find your next obsession.
Too many books, too little time. Filter the shelf by tropes, subgenre and spice level.
Where can I find book recommendations?
Start with the Romantasy Hub for genre-specific recommendations or browse the Book Reviews for more detailed opinions.
I cover books by tropes, tone, romance, pacing, and reader expectations, so you can find something suited to what you actually want to read. After all, recommending a book because it contains a dragon tells you very little about whether it’s any good.
What is The Gilt List Book Finder?
The Book Finder is a free interactive romantasy recommendation tool that helps you narrow down your next read.
You can filter the curated collection by subgenre, tropes, heat level, and whether you want a standalone. It’s particularly handy when you know you want enemies to lovers with a good amount of spice, but absolutely cannot face another unfinished six-book series.
How does The Gilt List review books?
Reviews focus on the experience of reading the book: pacing, characters, relationships, story payoff, tropes, and whether it delivers what its marketing promises.
Some reviews come from my own reading, while recommendation guides may also draw on research and reader feedback. The aim is to explain who a book suits, including its strengths and the reasons another reader might struggle with it.
What is the Gilt Score?
The Gilt Score is a 100-point review system that evaluates different aspects of a book, including romance, chemistry, worldbuilding, and emotional payoff.
It gives readers a consistent way to compare reviews, although the written breakdown matters just as much. A book with a lower score might still be your favourite if it happens to deliver exactly what you love.
Does The Gilt List recommend books on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes. Kindle Unlimited is a regular part of our book coverage, particularly for indie fantasy, romantasy, and romance readers.
Availability can change, so always check the retailer before subscribing or downloading a book specifically because of a recommendation.
Are The Gilt List reviews sponsored or affiliated?
Some articles contain affiliate links, which means The Gilt List may earn a commission if you make a qualifying purchase. This does not add to your purchase price.
Review copies and affiliate relationships do not guarantee positive coverage. You can read the full Affiliate & Review Disclosure for details.
Genres, spice & reader expectations
A few terms worth knowing before you commit to 600 pages of feelings.
What is the difference between romance, fantasy romance, and romantasy?
Romance centres on the development of a romantic relationship and, under established genre conventions, ends with an emotionally satisfying and optimistic romantic resolution.
Fantasy romance and romantasy combine a central love story with fantastical elements such as magic, invented worlds, supernatural creatures, or political systems. The two labels often overlap, although readers and publishers don’t always use them in exactly the same way.
Does The Gilt List only recommend spicy books?
No. You’ll find recommendations ranging from closed-door romance and cosy fantasy to explicit romantasy and darker fiction.
Where possible, recommendations explain both the heat level and the wider reading experience. A book can be spicy but emotionally gentle, or have no explicit sex whatsoever and still leave you staring at the ceiling at three in the morning.
What do spice levels mean?
Spice describes how explicit the sexual content is within a book. Closed-door or fade-to-black romance generally keeps sexual activity off the page, while open-door romance depicts intimacy directly. Higher-heat books may feature more frequent or more explicit scenes.
Our recommendations and reviews use spice information to help you choose, but heat ratings are guides rather than universal measurements.
What do HEA and HFN mean?
HEA means Happily Ever After, while HFN means Happy For Now. Both describe optimistic romantic resolutions, although HFN leaves more of the couple’s long-term future open.
If you don’t want an unresolved or tragic romantic ending, these are particularly important terms to check.
Does The Gilt List include content warnings?
I aim to flag significant content concerns where they’re known, especially in dark romance and dark romantasy.
However, individual reviews are not exhaustive content-warning databases. Check the author’s published warnings before reading if you need to avoid particular subjects or scenes.
Free tools for better stories
Planning, worldbuilding, and revision help. You still get to write the book.
Does The Gilt List offer free tools for writers?
Yes. The Gilt List has free interactive tools for developing story ideas, building fantasy worlds, planning plot structure, and reviewing the opening act of a manuscript.
These are designed to help you make decisions about your own writing. You don’t need to pay for an editorial service to begin using them.
What is the Story Idea Generator?
The Fantasy & Romantasy Story Idea Generator helps writers develop a story premise from curated ideas involving characters, worlds, relationships, conflict, and theme.
You can start with a completely new spark or shape an idea you already have. It’s ideal for writers who have an interesting character, trope, or setting but haven’t quite found the story yet.
Is there a free fantasy worldbuilding tool?
Yes. The World Bible Builder helps you organise the systems behind a fictional world, including geography, magic, culture, politics, religion, economics, and history.
You can use a shorter Quick Build or work through a more detailed World Bible. The tool also helps you decide which worldbuilding information readers need early in the story and which can wait.
Can I use The Gilt List to outline a novel?
Yes. The Novel Outline & Beat Planner walks you through major plot beats, character goals, conflict, relationship progression, and an optional chapter structure.
It’s designed for fantasy and romantasy writers who want a clearer story plan without having an automated system invent their plot.
What is the Act 1 Revision Tool?
The Act 1 Revision Tool is a free interactive checklist for evaluating your opening act.
It helps you examine major structural beats, character motivation, conflict, pacing, and whether your opening sets up the kind of story you’re trying to tell. You work through the questions yourself and receive guidance on areas that may need further revision.
Do The Gilt List writing tools use AI?
The current story-planning, worldbuilding, outline, and Act 1 tools do not use generative AI to write your story.
They use programmed questions, curated material, and structured logic to help you develop your own ideas. You remain responsible for the creative decisions, which is rather the point of writing a book.
Are there free writing checklists or downloadable guides?
Yes. Writers who join the Writer List can receive the First Chapter Checklist and the Info Dump & Worldbuilding Guide.
You can also browse the free Writing Craft Guides, covering first chapters, pacing, character development, worldbuilding, revision, querying, and other aspects of fiction writing.
Editing services for authors
What each critique covers, and how to choose the right amount of support.
Choose by the stage of your manuscript and how much support you want, rather than booking the biggest service by default.
Does The Gilt List offer professional editing services?
Yes. I offer four levels of story-focused editorial support: First Chapter Critiques, Fantasy Manuscript Critiques, Manuscript Diagnostic Reviews, and Full Developmental Editing.
Each option is designed for a different stage of revision and level of support. My current published services focus on fantasy, romantasy, urban fantasy, fantasy romance, and related speculative fiction. I also work with writers turning fanfiction adaptations and completed web serials into standalone novels.
What is a First Chapter Critique?
A First Chapter Critique examines your opening pages to see how effectively they introduce the story, engage readers, establish character goals, and communicate genre expectations.
There are three tiers, from a focused opening-page critique to a more detailed review with an editorial letter, revision plan, and calls. This is a good starting point if you’re preparing to query, reviewing your opening, or wondering why chapter one isn’t quite working.
What is a Fantasy Manuscript Critique?
The Fantasy Manuscript Critique is a lower-cost review of the whole manuscript.
I read your draft, identify the major developmental issues affecting the book, and explain which revisions deserve your attention first. The feedback is more focused than a full developmental edit and is suited to writers who want a professional assessment before investing in deeper support.
What is a Manuscript Diagnostic Review?
A Manuscript Diagnostic Review is a more comprehensive whole-book assessment.
It includes a full manuscript read and a substantial editorial letter covering structure, pacing, character and relationship arcs, worldbuilding, reader engagement, and revision priorities. It’s designed for writers who want a detailed diagnosis and feel comfortable carrying out the revisions independently.
You can find it on the Developmental Editing services page.
What is included in Full Developmental Editing?
Full Developmental Editing provides comprehensive feedback on the manuscript and more hands-on support through the revision process.
It includes the manuscript diagnosis and editorial letter, alongside chapter and scene notes, selected inline comments, a revision plan, and calls to discuss the work.
This option is designed for authors who want help understanding the problems in their draft and working through how to resolve them.
Do you edit fanfiction adaptations or Wattpad and Royal Road stories for publication?
Yes. I work with fantasy, romantasy, and urban fantasy authors turning fanfiction adaptations or completed serialized stories from Wattpad, Royal Road, and similar platforms into novels for self-publishing or submission to literary agents.
The focus is the book: does its plot hold together beyond individual instalments, does the world make sense on its own, and will the characters and relationships work for readers who didn’t follow the original story? Depending on how much feedback you need, a Manuscript Critique, Diagnostic Review, or Full Developmental Edit may be the right fit. I don’t offer ongoing episode-by-episode serial editing.
Do you need to read the original fanfiction or web serial before editing my novel?
No, and it may actually be better if I haven’t. Your new readers might know nothing about the original fandom or online version. Reading the adapted manuscript with fresh eyes helps me spot the character history, worldbuilding, motivations, and emotional moments that only make sense if you already know the source. If anything important needs explaining, we can discuss it during the editorial process.
How do I know which editing service I need?
Start with the problem you’re trying to solve.
If you’re concerned about your opening, choose a First Chapter Critique. If you want a lighter whole-book assessment, look at the Fantasy Manuscript Critique. If you need a comprehensive editorial diagnosis and are confident revising alone, consider the Manuscript Diagnostic Review. If you want detailed guidance throughout the manuscript and support planning your revisions, choose Full Developmental Editing.
You can also contact me before booking. I’d rather help you choose the right level of editing than sell you a service your manuscript doesn’t need.
Do you use AI to critique or edit manuscripts?
No. Manuscripts submitted for my editorial services are read and evaluated by me, without AI manuscript processing.
Your story receives human developmental feedback based on craft, reader experience, and the genre expectations of the manuscript.
Do you offer line editing, copyediting, or proofreading?
My current services focus on developmental editing, manuscript critiques, and story-level feedback.
If your structure and character arcs are already working and you need sentence-level polishing, grammar corrections, or a final proofread, a specialist line editor or copyeditor is the appropriate next step.
How much do editing services cost?
Pricing depends on the service, manuscript length, and, for some options, the complexity of the book.
Current prices, tier inclusions, eligible discounts, and booking details are available on the individual First Chapter Critique, Manuscript Critique, and Developmental Editing pages.
Newsletters & getting in touch
Book recommendations, craft notes, and a way to reach a real person.
How do I join The Gilt List newsletter?
There are two mailing lists: one for readers and one for writers.
The Reader List covers book recommendations, reviews, trends, and new content. The Writer List focuses on craft advice, free resources, tools, and editorial service updates.
You can join either through the newsletter page. You can unsubscribe whenever you like.
How can I contact The Gilt List?
For editorial enquiries, questions about the website, or anything that hasn’t been answered above, use the contact page.
If you’re contacting me about a manuscript, include your genre, approximate word count, current stage of revision, and what you’re hoping to get help with. That makes it much easier to work out the next step.
