Is Amren Really Amren in A Court of Splintered Harmony? The Aidas Theory

I already thought Amren was up to something in A Court of Splintered Harmony. I even included her in my original fan theories article because I couldn’t get over some of the decisions she made throughout the book. But after seeing readers on TikTok picking apart her final conversation with Nesta, I’m now wondering whether the woman who met Nesta on the cliffs before she went to the Prison was Amren at all. Yeah, it’s truly that dramatic.

The theory is that Amren is being impersonated by Aidas, the Prince of the Chasm from Crescent City, and the biggest clue involves Bryce Quinlan. Amren calls her “Miss Quinlan”, something Aidas is known to do, and then has an unusually formal conversation with Nesta, which feels off, before sending her to the Prison with Gwydion.

You know, where the sword promptly disappears.

The Amren Theory: Follow the Clues

I think there might be something to this theory, especially when we consider how much Maas has already connected the two worlds. And even if the woman on those cliffs really is Amren, her involvement in Nesta’s final journey is a little…suspicious.

Spoilers ahead for A Court of Splintered Harmony, Crescent City, Throne of Glass and the earlier ACOTAR books. If you haven’t finished them, consider yourself warned.

Want my actual reaction to the book before we start accusing everyone of impersonation? Here’s my Splintered Harmony review. Spoilers are marked there, too.

If the crossover lore has your head spinning, the reader list has a Book Finder and more reading recommendations while we untangle all this. Then it’s back to the conspiracies.

Why Do Readers Think Amren Isn’t Really Amren?

It all began…with the dialogue.

In the final part of Splintered Harmony, Amren meets Nesta as she’s preparing to travel to the Prison. She says she’s been travelling with Varian and sensed Nesta nearby, which explains why she’s there. She then starts helping Nesta understand her new winnowing abilities and what she might be capable of doing.

At first, there isn’t much reason to question these motives. Amren knows more about ancient magic and the Cauldron than almost anyone else in the Night Court, so having her explain something to Nesta makes sense. She’s also had a complicated relationship with Nesta for several books, and while the two have fallen out, they’ve also been unusually close at times. So, nothing crazy yet.

But there’s something odd about this conversation, and it becomes more noticeable when you look at the exact words she’s using.

Why Does Amren Call Bryce “Miss Quinlan”?

This is my favourite clue because it’s such a small detail, and I do so love when readers spot something that makes the rest of us go hunting through three other books to see if we’ve seen it before.

Amren refers to Bryce as “Miss Quinlan”, which is rather formal for a woman who spends most of her time insulting people, threatening them, or generally reminding everyone that she’s older and, you know… more frightening than they are.

And wait for it…Aidas, the Prince of the Chasm in Crescent City, uses that particular way of addressing Bryce ALL. THE. TIME.

Page 288 of A Court of Splintered Harmony highlights Amren calling Bryce Miss Quinlan

Readers in a November discussion about Splintered Harmony picked up on the wording and started questioning whether Amren was actually Aidas in disguise, dun dun dun. The theory has also been circulating on TikTok, where people are comparing the conversation with scenes from the earlier books.

This is all very plausible.

Maas has a habit of using small details to connect characters and storylines across her books. Sometimes it’s a sword, a symbol, or a particular description of magic. In this case, it could be a way of speaking. It’s not like this hasn’t been done before in other stories.

There are other things about Amren’s behaviour that don’t quite fit to boot.

Why Is Amren Speaking So Formally to Nesta?

Readers have also noticed Amren addressing Nesta by her full name, Nesta Archeron.

Now, Amren isn’t exactly affectionate at the best of times, let’s be fair, but she and Nesta have known each other for yeeeeeears.

Page 213 highlights Amren apologising to Feyre and Feyre noting how rare that is

And then there’s the way Amren starts telling Nesta what she should do. She encourages her to explore the Prison’s forgotten passages, tells her to find whatever has been calling to her, and specifically instructs her to take Gwydion. Nesta even suggests Ataraxia instead, but Amren insists on Gwydion…fishy. And what happens after that? Yup, Gwydion is snatched.

If this is true, it goes to show how good Maas is at making characters feel so real on the page that you can spot right away when they’re not acting like themselves.

Ready for more mic drops?

We have another incident in Splintered Harmony that makes this even more interesting. And actually this one had me screaming whaaaat?!? No she wouldn’t.

Amren apologises to Feyre.

Nesta has never heard Amren apologise, a line from Chapter 24 of Splintered Harmony

And yes, I went back and checked. She actually says she’s sorry. Feyre even notices how rare an apology is from Amren, which is the sort of thing that makes me start paying attention.

Later, Nesta is surprised when Amren suggests she should apologise to Rhys because she’s never heard Amren apologise herself. Of course, Nesta wasn’t there for the conversation with Feyre, so both reactions make sense. But I do find it interesting that Maas draws attention to Amren’s attitude toward apologies twice.

Perhaps Amren is changing after everything that’s happened to her? Maybe she’s turning over a new leaf or something. She lost her original powers when she returned from the Cauldron, and she’s spent years adjusting to being High Fae rather than the ancient creature she once was. So…maybe she’s become more…soft?

Or maybe it’s not her.

Why Does Amren Appear Just as Nesta Is Trying to Reach the Prison?

There’s also the timing of this conversation, which I think is worth looking at because…weird.

Nesta is on the cliffs across from the Prison, trying to work out how to winnow there, when Amren appears…seemingly for no reason. She explains that she’s been travelling with Varian and sensed Nesta nearby.

But I’m wondering whether she really did happen across Nesta by chance or if that’s all on purpose.

Amren (and likely others too) knows Nesta has been experimenting with her abilities, and she knows the Prison is connected to some very old magic. She also seems really freaking interested in what Nesta might find there, maybe too interested.

Hmmm. Seems very specific for someone who was “just in the neighborhood”.

Page 290 highlights Amren telling Nesta to explore the Prison and bring Gwydion

If we’re entertaining the idea that Aidas is impersonating her, because fun, perhaps he knew Nesta would be there and deliberately intercepted her before she could reach the Prison.

If it’s the real Amren, I still wonder whether she had a reason for seeking Nesta out. If so, what is she actually up to?

Is Amren Actually Aidas From Crescent City?

Crescent City spoilers ahead.

Aidas is a pretty good candidate for the impersonation theory, mostly because he has a connection to the ancient history surrounding Gwydion and the Dusk Court.

For anyone who hasn’t read Crescent City recently, Aidas is one of the Princes of Hel. He’s known as the Prince of the Chasm, and he has a long history with Bryce’s ancestor, Queen Theia, who ruled the ancient Fae before the events that eventually separated their worlds.

He also has the ability to appear in different forms. We first meet him as a white cat, and his identity and intentions become much more important as Bryce discovers the truth about the Asteri.

Theia is particularly relevant because of her connection to the Starsword, which is the same weapon as Gwydion in ACOTAR. It was originally a sword from Prythian before Theia and her people crossed into Midgard, taking their history, their magic and some rather important weapons with them. Phew. Glad we’re all caught up.

Now, remember what happens in House of Flame and Shadow? Bryce accidentally travels into Prythian carrying the Starsword, where she meets Nesta and Azriel. They end up exploring the tunnels beneath the Prison, and Bryce discovers the history of the lost Dusk Court, including what happened to Theia and her daughters. Eventually, Bryce escapes back to Midgard, taking the Starsword with her.

But that’s not the end of Gwydion’s little holiday.

After Bryce defeats the Asteri, she returns to Prythian to collect her parents and return the Mask and Truth-Teller. And this is where she gives the Starsword to Nesta, permanently.

House of Earth and Blood by Sarah J. Maas book cover

The reason is what makes the exchange so important.

Bryce remembers that Nesta had an eight-pointed star tattooed on her, and that she’d found a chamber beneath the Prison marked with that same symbol. Bryce believes there’s a connection between Nesta, the sword and the ancient Dusk Court, so she tells Nesta to keep Gwydion and discover what that connection means.

If you need a refresher on how the series connect, I have a separate Crescent City and ACOTAR crossover guide.

Now, back to Aidas.

He knew Queen Theia personally, understands the history of the Starborn, and knows far more about the ancient war between the Fae and the Asteri than most people still living. He also knows the significance of the Starsword and how Theia’s magic was divided after her defeat.

So imagine Aidas learning that the Starsword has finally returned to Prythian, and that Bryce has given it to a woman with a connection to the very place Theia once ruled.

Wouldn’t he want to know what happens next? Maybe he knows something we’re all missing in the myths as well and we’re about to find out some secrets.

But here’s what I’m stuck on. Why pretend to be Amren?

Nesta has already helped Bryce, despite knowing exactly how much trouble she’d be in with Rhys afterwards. If Aidas needed her help, I don’t think she’d automatically refuse him. Depending on what he wanted, she might even be rather interested.

Unless he doesn’t want her to know he’s involved.

Maybe Aidas isn’t allowed to interfere directly. Maybe there’s some ancient agreement between worlds that prevents him from simply walking into Prythian and getting what he wants. Or perhaps he knows Nesta would ask questions he doesn’t want to answer, particularly about Theia and the history of the Dusk Court.

I do like the idea that he’s trying to help. His relationship with Theia gives him a personal reason to care about what happened to her people, and I’d love to find out more about that history. But impersonating someone Nesta trusts would be a pretty questionable way of going about it.

Then again, this is a man who introduced himself as a cat. Maybe straightforward introductions aren’t his thing. And if you’re following the crossover beyond this book, I’ve got the Crescent City and ACOTAR connection covered separately.

Could Apollion Be Impersonating Amren, or Working With Aidas?

A Court of Splintered Harmony by Sarah J. Maas book cover, pink-to-orange gradient with black ornate design

Okay, now I have another suspect to throw into the mix.

Apollion.

Aidas’s brother, the Prince of the Pit, the Star-Eater. You know, the one who killed an Asteri and ate her. Very reassuring for everyone involved, I’m sure.

So I was reading Nesta’s conversation with Amren and there was this moment where Amren appears to read her thoughts. Cue alarm bells for me. Then I remembered Apollion, who can get inside people’s heads.

Remember when he visits Hunt in House of Sky and Breath? Hunt thinks he’s dreaming, but Apollion explains that they’ve met in a pocket-realm between their worlds. He can respond to Hunt’s thoughts there, even though Hunt hasn’t spoken them aloud.

And then Apollion indicates that he could enter Bryce’s mind if he wanted to. Apparently Aidas wouldn’t be very happy about that, which also tells us something about their relationship. These brothers have boundaries. Sort of. Kind of. I mean, they are ancient beings.

We’ve also seen Apollion appear in different forms, including when he visits Bryce.

So now we’ve got another Prince of Hel who can change his appearance, has experience communicating through someone’s thoughts, and has already been involved in manipulating events across worlds.

So I mean. Why not him over his brother?

Or…

What if Aidas and Apollion are working together?

Aidas has the personal connection to Theia and Gwydion. Apollion has demonstrated the sort of mental abilities that might help someone fool Nesta. We’ve already seen the brothers coordinate their plans against the Asteri, so it wouldn’t be the first time they worked toward the same goal.

Maybe Aidas wants something returned to the Dusk Court, while Apollion is the one who makes sure Nesta gets there.

Or maybe Apollion has decided to interfere on his own because just maybe the interest in Gwydion has less to do with restoring the Dusk Court and more to do with opening something beneath it.

We know Apollion is interested in the connections between worlds. What if he needs an entrance that Bryce never opened?

Okay, but who is actually pretending to be Amren?

Could Nesta Be Opening a Gateway Between Worlds?

Another thought I can’t get out of my head is Nesta’s winnowing, because it has been a bit odd throughout the book.

We know travelling between worlds is possible. Bryce has already done it. And the strange mist and thin-place descriptions around Nesta’s attempts to winnow stood out to me during my first read, long before I started looking into the Amren theory. It’s planted on purpose for sure.

What if Nesta is finding places where the boundaries between worlds are weaker?

I’ve been assuming the Dusk Court is where all this is heading, like pretty much everyone else. But perhaps restoring the court is only one part of whatever Nesta is meant to do. What if the old Dusk Court had access to other worlds, and that’s why its history is so important?

Or maybe Nesta is about to open something everyone else worked very hard to keep shut.

I would love a bigger adventure here. Not just a straightforward quest. Something so mind-blowing it starts a whole new series.

Is Amren a Valg, and What Is Her True Form in ACOTAR?

So, sure, Amren could be someone else. Or maybe her true form is connected to the Valg from Throne of Glass.

Amren has always been one of the most mysterious characters in ACOTAR. She came from another world, spent thousands of years imprisoned, and eventually took a Fae body so she could live among the people of Prythian. So she has her secrets, and a deep well of knowledge.

In A Court of Wings and Ruin, we finally see her release that body and return to her original form, a terrifying creature associated with fire and light. She destroys Hybern’s forces before being brought back through the Cauldron, returning as High Fae without the same extraordinary powers. Badass for sure.

But is that consistent with what we know about the Valg?

Ehhh, I’m not completely sold.

The Valg can possess people and influence their minds, so that part certainly fits the possibility of someone walking around in Amren’s body. But the form we saw during the war against Hybern doesn’t really resemble the shadowy, parasitic creatures we’ve encountered in Throne of Glass.

There’s also a new clue in Nesta’s conversation with Amren that not enough people are talking about.

Nesta remembers what Bryce told her about the eight-pointed star tattoo. Amren then nods as though she’s somehow heard that memory inside Nesta’s head.

Ummm. Excuse me?

Amren nods as though she heard Nesta's private memory of Bryce in Chapter 24

Now, this doesn’t necessarily mean Amren has read her mind. But why write it that way if she hasn’t?

And if the woman standing in front of Nesta isn’t Amren, that little moment is a huge clue.

Think about Maeve in Throne of Glass. She’s a Valg queen who uses mental manipulation to convince people she’s someone she isn’t. She changes what they remember, influences their perceptions and manages to build an entire identity around a lie. And what do we know of the team in this book? Many key players not acting like themselves.

If a powerful Valg has entered Prythian, they wouldn’t necessarily need to rely on a convincing costume. We’re seeing this book through other characters’ points of view and memories, so a manipulation like that could play out right in front of us.

Also. Just to add on.

There’s been talk about Erebos, Azriel’s shadows and whether the darker magic appearing in the new books has Valg connections, so maybe this is much deeper. Maybe Az’s shadows are connected to an impostor Valg that’s scared off by Elain. Haha, now it’s getting really wild.

I’m just not convinced Amren herself is the missing Valg connection though.

Someone possessing her, or creating that impression in others, though? That I could get behind.

And what a choice of person to impersonate. Rhys has relied on Amren’s advice for centuries, and very few people would feel comfortable challenging her about what she knows. If I were an ancient creature trying to manipulate the Night Court, well now, that would be my in for sure.

It would also give us a sinister explanation for that apology to Feyre. Perhaps it wasn’t about making amends at all. Perhaps someone was trying to get back into her good books after their argument. Someone willing to butter them all up until just the right moment.

What If Amren Really Is Amren and She’s Manipulating Everyone?

I don’t think we should overlook the possibility that Amren is perfectly capable of all this without any help from Aidas, Apollion, Koschei or the Valg. I mean. She’s Amren.

We’ve seen her conceal information before. Remember what happened with the Cauldron in A Court of Wings and Ruin? She knew considerably more than Feyre did, and she was prepared to use that advantage because she believed releasing her true form was necessary to win the war.

She was right about the threat, but that doesn’t mean her methods were…great.

And now we have Splintered Harmony, where Amren is already frustrated with Feyre and Rhys for failing to take stronger action against the growing problems in Prythian. So why not get a little tricky? It’s not like either of them seems really interested in taking advice.

Then Bryaxis attacks Nyx.

After that, Rhys begins reconsidering his approach and the entire Night Court is forced to take the threat more seriously. I wondered in my earlier theories article whether Amren might have known something about the attack, or even had a hand in encouraging the events that led to it. For this very outcome.

If she’s not really Amren, that’s a super dark take.

And if she is? Well, it worked.

I’m also wondering whether Amren knows something about Nesta that the rest of the Inner Circle doesn’t. Their relationship has always been unusual, and Amren seems to understand how to push Nesta in ways other characters struggle with. It’s almost as though she’s dealt with someone like her before.

What if she has? What if she knew an ancestor?

She’s lived through many, many things, and I can’t imagine she’s told us the half of them.

And man, if she’s been moving everyone around like pieces on a board, especially after what happened to Nyx, then pass me the popcorn already.

What Does the Amren Theory Mean for A Court of Forgotten Melody?

No matter what, Amren’s advice is at the centre of something. Nesta reaches the Prison, and Gwydion disappears. Someone wanted her to go there with that sword, and I’m having a hard time believing it was all a coincidence.

I’m leaning toward Aidas knowing more about the Dusk Court than he’s told anyone. But now I’m also wondering whether Apollion might have something to do with it, especially if the brothers have been planning something together.

And if it’s Apollion acting alone? That could be an even bigger problem.

What if Amren and the Princes of Hel actually know each other? Now there’s a thought.

Whatever happens, I’m rooting for Nesta and the Dusk Court Queen storyline.

One thing that bothered me about House of Flame and Shadow was the way Rhys reacted when Nesta helped Bryce. She made a difficult choice, and everyone seemed much more interested in whether she’d had permission than in why she made it.

We’ve had enough of that. Give Nesta the crown. The rest can take a seat.

For more unhinged takes, you can also read my ten biggest Splintered Harmony fan theories, where I’ve gone into the Dusk Court, Clotho’s suspicious ribbon, Nesta and Cassian, Elain’s powers, and what I think Maas might be planning for the rest of the Valkyrie Cycle.

For Writers: Strong Characters Make Clues Like This Possible

Okay, putting my developmental editor hat on for a moment. Today it’s an old timey english hat. You know the one. Annnyway.

The reason we’re all going mad over “Miss Quinlan” is that we’ve spent several books learning what Amren sounds like. We know her temper, her way of talking to people, what she tends to reveal and what she holds back. So when something is slightly off, readers notice.

You should create that effect in your own fantasy novel, too. You can do this by giving your characters core wounds, and the precise way they handle that wound….and make sure they stay consistent about it. The reason we know Amren doesn’t apologize, is because of who she thinks she is, not because it’s a little quirk someone mentioned once.

And while you’re at it, give your characters consistent habits, desires and reactions that belong to them. Those behaviours should come from their goals and fears, not mannerisms (although, some can help). I wrote more about that in how character desire and primal fear drive a fantasy story.

Once readers know a character, you can change one small thing and they will know it….which is not great if you do it by accident, so utilize betas and editors who have read your other stories, if this is a series. Now characters will change, that’s a given. If a reader notices a change and it feels off, like Amren, it’s either because it’s supposed to feel off (when done well), or because this part of their arc doesn’t feel earned (her willing to apologize).

This is the kind of character consistency and reader experience I look at when editing fantasy and romantasy. If you’re not sure your characters are coming across on the page the way they do in your head, my first chapter critiques can help with those opening impressions. For a character arc or mystery that needs to hold together across a whole book, have a look at my developmental editing services. And then go give your readers people they know so well, they can predict what they would do next.

Editorial Services
Professional support for your manuscript
Get the editorial feedback your story needs
Whether you need a focused critique on your opening chapters, a lower-cost full manuscript critique before beta readers, or a deeper developmental edit, I provide actionable, EFA-certified guidance for fantasy and romantasy writers.

Want the craft side of these rabbit holes? My writer email list is separate from the reader newsletter: revision notes, practical writing tools and news about editorial availability. This one’s for the WIP, not the TBR.

📬 Recently subscribed? If you haven’t received your welcome resources, please check your Spam or Promotions folders.
The Gilt List
For Writers
Critique, Craft & What’s Coming
Revision & outline tools to help your story be the best it can be. Plus, news, craft notes, and genre-aware advice for fantasy and romantasy writers.
Now Open
Editorial Critiques
10% off manuscript revision critique from a genre-aware editor. Hook, pacing, voice, beats, & reader fit.
Now Open
Writerly Tools
Story building and revision tools for fantasy writers. Step-by-step tools to help you revise your WIP or start a new one on the right foot.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from The Gilt List. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Frequently Asked Questions About the ACOSH Amren Theory

Is Amren really Amren at the end of A Court of Splintered Harmony?

That’s what readers are questioning after her conversation with Nesta in Chapter 24. Her unusual language has led to theories that someone might be impersonating her, although the scene could also mean Amren has her own plans for Nesta.

Why does Amren call Bryce Miss Quinlan?

Fans noticed that Aidas uses the same form of address for Bryce in Crescent City. It’s a small detail, but one that’s made readers wonder whether he’s the person speaking to Nesta.

Could Apollion be impersonating Amren?

It’s another possibility worth exploring. Apollion can appear in different forms and has demonstrated the ability to communicate through thoughts in a realm between worlds. He could be helping Aidas, or acting for his own reasons. Neither possibility has been confirmed.

Can Apollion read minds in Crescent City?

Apollion responds to Hunt’s thoughts during their encounter in House of Sky and Breath and indicates that entering someone’s mind is possible for him. That makes him particularly interesting in light of Nesta’s impression that Amren somehow heard her memory of Bryce.

Is Amren a Valg?

Amren hasn’t been identified as a Valg. Her original form appeared to be something quite different, although Valg possession is one possible explanation if someone else has taken her place.

What happened to Gwydion at the end of Splintered Harmony?

Gwydion disappears after Nesta enters the Prison. We don’t yet know why, although its connection to the ancient Dusk Court makes the location particularly interesting.

Will A Court of Forgotten Melody reveal who Amren really is?

A Court of Forgotten Melody is scheduled for January 12, 2027. I’m hoping we’ll get answers about the Prison, Gwydion and whether Amren was telling Nesta everything she knew.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *